A branch of the National Institutes of Health is
investigating three Veterans Affairs Medical Centers for performing
experiments on patients without their consent, CNN has learned.
The probe comes in advance of a congressional hearing next week into similar
charges at the West Los Angeles Veterans Affairs Medical Center, the largest
veterans hospital in the country.
The three new targeted veterans facilities are in Philadelphia, Cincinnati
and Tampa. Florida.
"Research is important to our veterans, but it has to be done correctly,"
says U.S. Rep. Terry Everett (R-Alabama). "You can't take veterans and treat
them like animals by ignoring their requests that they don't want to be
guinea pigs, and then doing this experimentation anyhow."
The chief research officer for the Department of Veterans Affairs tells CNN
he thinks the investigations in Tampa and Cincinnati involve private medical
centers that have close relationships with the veterans hospitals, and is not
sure whether they involve veteran patients.
Cheryl Alvarado has been asked to testify next week at the congressional
hearing in Washington. In 1995, her father, Robert Hanson, 71, died after
treatment at the West Los Angeles facility.
She says he was given experimental drugs. No one from the hospital would
comment, but Alvarado says she was told her father died of a heart attack.
"I think that people should go into the hospital feeling the doctors are
going to help them, not go in there and have something done to them that
shouldn't have been done to them," she says.
One noted expert on medical ethics says that informed consent is important
because patients may not realize that the main purpose of research is
producing knowledge, not helping patients.
"We have to have some protection to make it as safe as possible and that
people get enrolled only when they are as aware as they can be that this is a
research project," Alex Capron says.
The problem is deemed so serious that more than 1,000 research projects have
been suspended at the West Los Angeles facility. Whether similar actions will
take place at the three additional facilities under scrutiny remains unknown.
In all, 173 Veterans Affairs facilities treat more than 1 million U.S.
veterans each year.